For a B2C transaction in which a customer returns an item worth RM100 and buys a new item worth RM200, paying only the RM100 difference, can both transactions be recorded in one e-Invoice or receipt, or must separate documents be issued?
According to HASiL’s guidance, a business may issue e-Invoices in line with its existing business practices, provided the transaction is clearly and accurately reflected. If the point-of-sale (POS) system supports recording the return and new sale in one document, a single e-Invoice may be issued. If the system cannot process them together, the business may issue two separate e-Invoices or receipts: one for the return and one for the new sale.
One Combined e-Invoice
For example, a customer returns a T-shirt worth RM100 and buys a jacket worth RM200, paying the RM100 difference. If the system supports combining both transactions in one document, the e-Invoice may show:
- Returned item (T-shirt): RM100, recorded as a negative line item
- New item (jacket): RM200
- Net amount payable: RM100
Two Separate e-Invoices
If the system cannot properly offset the return against the new sale, the business may issue:
- A credit note for the returned item: RM100
- An e-Invoice for the new sale of the jacket: RM200
The customer pays the RM100 difference.
Either approach may be used, provided the e-Invoice accurately reflects the transaction and follows the business’s existing POS or accounting process.
B2C 电子发票中的退货与换货:应开一张还是两张?
在 B2C 交易中,顾客退回一件价值 RM100 的商品,同时购买一件价值 RM200 的新商品,并只支付 RM100 的差额。商家可以在同一张电子发票或收据中处理这两项交易,还是必须分别开具凭证?
根据内陆税收局(HASiL)的说明,商家可以按照现有的商业实务开具电子发票,前提是交易内容得到清楚、准确的反映。如果销售点系统(POS)支持在同一张凭证中处理退货与新购交易,商家可以开具一张合并电子发票。如果系统无法一并处理,则可以分别开具两张电子发票或收据:一张用于退货,另一张用于新购商品。
开具一张合并电子发票
例如,顾客退回一件价值 RM100 的 T-shirt,并购买一件价值 RM200 的外套,支付 RM100 的差额。如果系统支持在同一张凭证中处理两项交易,电子发票可列明:
- 退回商品(T-shirt):RM100,以负数行项目列示
- 新购商品(外套):RM200
- 应付净额:RM100
分别开具两张电子发票
如果系统无法妥善抵销退货金额与新购金额,商家可以分别开具:
- 退回商品的贷项通知单:RM100
- 新购外套的电子发票:RM200
顾客支付 RM100 的差额。
只要电子发票准确反映交易,并符合商家现有的 POS 或会计处理流程,上述两种做法均可采用。
